Ideas worth pondering—Leon Wieseltier
Posted by Denis Haack in culture, Humanness, Meaning, News, Technology, Wisdom
In “Among the Disrupted,” the cover essay for the New York Times Book Review (January 18,
2015) Leon Wieseltier laments how devices are often valued over books,
technology seems ascendant over the humanities, hunger for instant information
has replaced the long search for wisdom, and the meaning of humanity has been
reduced to the mechanistic. All worthy concerns, I would say, even if you or I
would parse things differently in places from Mr. Wieseltier.
You can read his essay here.
And to get you started pondering the ideas Wieseltier
raises, here are few quotes from “Among the Disrupted”:
“Journalistic
institutions slowly transform themselves into silent sweatshops in which words
cannot wait for thoughts, and first responses are promoted into best responses,
and patience is a professional liability. As the frequency of expression grows,
the force of expression diminishes: Digital expectations of alacrity and
terseness confer the highest prestige upon the twittering cacophony of
one-liners and promotional announcements. It was always the case that all thing
must pass, but this is ridiculous.”
“The
distinction between knowledge and information is a thing of the past, and there
is no greater disgrace than to be a thing of the past.”
“Aside from
issues of life and death, there is no more urgent task for American
intellectuals and writers than to think critically about the salience, even the
tyranny, of technology in individual and collective life.”
“The
processing of information is not the highest aim to which the human spirit can
aspire, and neither is competitiveness in a global economy. The character of
our society cannot be determined by engineers.”
“Every
technology is used before it is completely understood. There is always a lag
between an innovation and the apprehension of its consequences. We are living
in that lag, and it is a right time to keep our heads and reflect. We have much
to gain and much to lose. In the media, for example, the general inebriation
about the multiplicity of platforms has distracted many people from the scruple
that questions of quality on the new platforms should be no different from
questions of quality on the old platforms. Otherwise a quantitative expansion
will result in a qualitative contraction. The new devices do not in themselves
authorize a revision of the standards of evidence and argument and style that
we championed in the old devices.”
From the usual definition of fear—a distressing, unpleasant
emotion evoked by the dread of or threat of imminent harm—we’d assume people
don’t line up to pay good money to be frightened. But the lines outside haunted
houses and theaters showing horror films prove us wrong. We don’t like being
afraid but somehow are attracted to fear.
I wonder if this love of being scared isn’t hardwired into
us as human beings. Created as finite we exist as tiny creatures in an
expansive cosmos, and so live on the edge of a greatness that shocks our
imagination. Called into existence by God’s word, if God were to withdraw his
sustaining word we would tumble back into the nothingness from which we came.
And in a fallen world we live knowing that death shadows us, and every glimpse
into that abyss once again underscores our finitude. Not surprising then, that
biblical incidents where people experience the presence of God and his angelic
warriors find them struck down with fear (Isaiah 6:5; Daniel 8:17; Revelation
1:17). Nor is it surprising that a healthy fear of the Almighty is a sign of
wisdom and maturity, demonstrating an ability to rightly discern reality
(Proverbs 1:7; 1 Peter 2:17).
Thus the yearning for spirituality, for God, for meaning
that transcends the narrow confines of time and space includes a search for a
proper fear. We find this unpleasant response somehow strangely attractive,
needed to jolt us into a sense that we might after all exist.
Perhaps this explains the attractiveness of places like The Nightmares Fear Factory, a tourist attraction at Niagara Falls, Canada, billed
as “The World’s Most Frightening Experience.” It takes fifteen minutes or less
to walk through it, and at the corner in which the fear peaks The Factory has
installed a camera. They post pictures online (which you can see here).
My question is: why are these pictures so funny?
[Source: Thanks to Andrew Sullivan on The Dish, where I
first heard about The Nightmares Fear Factory.]
A lovely addition to a web crowded with stuff
Posted by Denis Haack in Christian faith, Hospitality, Humanness, Margie Haack, Ransom Fellowship, Wisdom
This past week my best friend and wife and co-worker
launched a sub-set of Ransom’s web site called Margie’s Stuff. You can find it
here.
On Margie’s Stuff there are essays, short pieces, recipes,
audio recordings, and a link to her blog, Toads Drink Coffee. She has an
uncanny ability to tell stories of ordinary life while showing the
extraordinary ways grace reveals itself in humor and suffering and bright
glimpses of glory. That is something we were taught by Francis Schaeffer back
in the Sixties—that faithfulness in the ordinary things of life is where true
significance is found—and Margie is better able to tease out the truth of that
better than anyone I know.
There is something refreshing about someone who publishes a
Bible reading program “for Slackers and Shirkers,” while insisting the title
refers to herself. Or who finds glimmers of grace in an infestation of moths in
her pantry, or who insists that cooking with cast iron can be glorifying to God
even if you aren’t doing it for a church potluck, or who finds simple
hospitality a chance to bring a measure of healing and rest into busy people’s
lives. The sort of person who can read the Christmas story and find this:
From the Advent story
one of the characters we don’t hear much about because she’s such a minor
player is Anna. What attracts me is that she’s old, like really old. Luke tells
us “she was advanced in years, having lived with her husband seven years from when
she was a virgin, and then as a widow until she was eighty-four. She never left
the temple worshiping with fasting and prayer night and day” (Luke 2: 35-37).
It seems she never forgot the memories of her young husband and his untimely
death which could have left her angry and bitter. Probably her joints ached,
her skin sucked, and her eyes got gunkier each morning. From a modern
perspective she didn’t have much of a life, although her contemporaries called
her a prophetess. One morning in walks this couple with a baby, one among
hundreds, maybe thousands she’s already seen, but she has the clarity of
truthfulness and purpose that helps her recognize something different about
this baby—he’s The Christ of God. She walks over to touch this child that all the
world is waiting for, and there in front of everyone she blesses him and thanks
God.
In the Gospel of Luke
in the chapter just before we hear about Anna, Zachariah, the father of John
the Baptist, says a profound thing, and I think it captures exactly what Anna
was doing with her life. He says that the Messiah is going “…to rescue us from
the hand of our enemies, and to enable us to serve him without fear in holiness
and righteousness before him all our days…” (Luke 1:74,75) Which is exactly
what Anna was doing, right there in the temple with corns on her toes and moles
on her neck.
If I am busy
considering either my body or time as enemies then I have succumbed to a
limited perspective which is informed by my senses and, more subtly, by
cultural pressures that determine whether we are good, successful, disciplined,
worthy people, thanks to iCalendar, diet, and proper exercise. Both body and
time are gifts that enable me to serve God in holiness and righteousness
“before him (embodied) all our days.” That means being contented with
twenty-four hour days where God says it’s good to live – from babyhood to end
the of life. If I understand Anna’s life correctly, this child she blessed has
the power to transform our fearful concentration on self (in whatever form),
forgive our complaints, and direct us in acts of service to others.
So, I commend Margie’s Stuff to you. Not because I have too,
but because on a world wide web crowded with nonsense and knowledge, it is a
space devoted to wisdom.
Reflecting on good news
Posted by Denis Haack in Christian faith, Creation, Discernment, Redemption, Shalom, Wisdom, World
My blog today is simple: just two quotes, both wise I think,
that I hope you will reflect on and then leave a comment about what comes to
mind.
Both remind us of truths that are often forgotten today in
the church, if not heatedly refuted. Both are vital, for the health of our
spirituality and for what the watching world sees in us concerning our faith.
To believe both and try to live accordingly will perhaps result in criticism
from fellow Christians. To believe both and live accordingly is to go against
the flow—to resist the most common thought forms and dominant practices
embraced by the wider evangelical community. So it takes courage to do so, and
care that we don’t slide into a smug pride that we aren’t like all the rest.
What is at stake is the gospel.
“We do not draw people to Christ by loudly discrediting what
they believe, by telling them how wrong they are and how right we are, but by
showing them a light that is so lovely that they want with all their hearts to
know the source of it.” (Madeleine L’Engle in Walking on Water
: Reflections on Faith and Art; page 122.)
“To identify the church as the sole locus of God's
redemptive concern is badly to misunderstand the scheme of salvation. Indeed,
it is to invert it. God wants the whole world back, not just a selection of
human beings. And he wants it back not to bask in the eternal adoration of the
redeemed saints, as per the vision offered at the end of Dante’s Paradiso and in countless lesser
depictions of heaven, but to enjoy the give-and-take of shalom with all his
creatures and among them as well. To repeat, therefore: the church performs its
distinctive redemptive calling within, and in the service of, the general call
of God upon humanity to be stewards of the whole earth God loves.” (John
Stackhouse, Making the Best of It
:
Following Christ in the Real World, p. 237. Thanks to my friend Steve
Froehlich for this one.)
I look forward to reading your reflections and reactions in
the comments you leave.
I have a riddle for you. Imagine walking to an appointment
or to do some shopping and coming across someone you know looking out into an
open field. It includes a few trees, say, or perhaps it’s part of a farm or a
section of land inside the city set aside for community gardens. Your friend is
just looking, quite intently, and without realizing what you are doing you
pause and watch. Your friend keeps right on looking. You look at the field and
don’t see anything particularly newsworthy. It’s a field. There are a few birds,
I’ve already mentioned the trees, and though some of it has been carefully
cultivated, parts are quite wild. A shopkeeper from across the way happens by
and comments about your friend, “They’ve been there for hours, you know. Came
two days last week, too.” The shopkeeper shakes their head and walks on. Your
friend is not a biologist, and has no stake personally in this piece of land.
They are simply looking very intently at a field.
Here is the riddle: what are they doing?
Of course, there are many possible answers. They might be
taking a break from a busy day doing something they find deeply relaxing. They
might be thinking about something that has nothing to do with the field but
that requires a quiet place where they won’t be interrupted. Since I’m a
product of the Sixties, one possibility that comes to mind is that they might be
stoned. They might be overwhelmed by secret guilt and are trying to convince
themselves not to commit suicide. They might be secretly lazy, this being
merely one manifestation of their ability to waste enormous chunks of time.
They might… we could, no doubt, fill out the list of possibilities endlessly.
If our minds and imaginations are shaped by the ancient
writings of the Bible, however, one possibility should have come instantly to
mind. It is possible they are gaining wisdom.
Jesus told his followers to spend time watching birds,
considering flowers, and looking at the grass (Matthew 6:25-30). If we did, he
said, we would learn something important about ourselves and about God. Solomon
“saw” and “considered” and “looked” at a field, and as a result “received
instruction” (Proverbs 24: 30-32) that in turn caused him to write a proverb
(33-34). When his wisdom was described, his expertise on trees, animals, birds,
reptiles, and fish is included in the list (1 Kings 5:33). After Job had lost
his family, his wealth, and his health, gone through more loss and grief than I
can imagine, suffered so much, God had him stand still and look at the creation
(Job 38-41) so that the deepest questions of his heart could find an answer.
The Hebrew psalmist David, perhaps when he was out alone caring for his
father’s sheep, looked up at the sky and learned of God (Psalm 19:1). St Paul
argued that moral responsibility was inescapable because human beings were
creatures in a creation that revealed enough about God that order and a sense
of right was the only possible sane conclusion (Romans 1:18-32).
“There is a way that nature speaks, the land speaks,” Native
American environmentalist Linda Hogan says. “Most of the time we are simply not
patient enough, quiet enough, to pay attention to the story.”
Remember my riddle about finding a friend staring at a
field? My point—my regret, actually—is not that we don’t take the time to do
what they were doing—and that is a great loss—but that when we needed to guess
what they were doing we probably did not immediately think, “Of course! They
are gaining wisdom.” At least I did not. I am so captivated by my culture’s
fixation (the biblical term is idolatry)
on productivity and efficiency that the notion seems strange, if not wrong.
Which only goes to show how much I need wisdom.
Source: Linda
Hogan in The Sun (September 2010)
page 48.
Archives
Author
Followers
Categories
- 9/11
- A Glass Darkly
- Advent
- Africa
- America
- Anglican
- Apologetics
- Architecture
- Art
- Asking questions
- Avett Brothers
- Babylon
- Ballpoint pens
- Bavinck
- BB King
- Beauty
- Belief
- Bible
- Birds
- Blues
- Bob Lefsetz
- Body of Lies
- Bono
- Book review
- Brokenness
- Buddhism
- Business
- Busyness
- C.S.Lewis
- Calling
- Calvin
- Cartoons
- Cemetery
- Center for Public Justice
- Chaff
- Charles Taylor
- Christian faith
- Christina Rossetti
- Church
- Cigars
- CIVA
- Civility
- Cohabitation
- Colbert Report
- Community
- Confession
- Conservatism
- Contentment
- Conversation
- Covenant Theological Seminary
- Creation
- Creation care
- Creativity
- Credit cards
- Critique
- Crouch
- culture
- Dance
- Death
- Despair
- Discernment
- Disequilibrium
- Dooyeweerd
- Douthat
- Drugs
- Economics
- Ethics
- Eugene Peterson
- Evangelism
- Evil
- Farmer's Market
- Fiction
- Film review
- Financial crisis
- Food
- Foreign policy
- Forgiveness
- Francis Schaeffer
- Frederick Douglass
- freedom
- Fundamentalism
- G.K.Chesterton
- Globalization
- Glory
- Government
- Grace
- Gratitude
- Graveyard
- History
- Homosexuality
- Hope
- Hospitality
- Humanness
- Humility
- Humor
- Images
- Individualism
- Internet
- Iran
- ISIS
- Islam
- Israel
- J. I. Packer
- Jazz
- John Newton
- John Stott
- Justice
- Katie Bowser
- Kenny Hutson
- Law
- Leadership
- Legalism
- Lent
- Liberalism
- Lies
- Life
- Listening
- Love
- Luci Shaw
- Makoto Fujimura
- Margie Haack
- Markets
- Marriage
- Maturity
- Meals
- Meaning
- Medicine
- Memory
- Mercy
- Michael Pollan
- Middle East
- Millennial generation
- Minnesota
- Modernism
- Mongol
- Morality
- Movies
- Music
- Mystery
- New earth
- News
- North Korea
- Obama
- Offense
- Ordination
- Over the Rhine
- Pantheism
- Parenting
- Persecution
- Pharisee
- Philosophy
- Pluralism
- Plymouth Brethren
- Poetry
- politics
- Popular culture
- Postmodernism
- Postmodernity
- Poverty
- Prayer
- Presbyterian
- Pride
- Providence
- Questions
- Quotes
- Ransom Fellowship
- Reactionary
- Redemption
- Regret
- Relationships
- Relativism
- Religion
- Religious freedom
- Repentance
- Rest
- Resurrection
- Ridley Scott
- Rockies
- Sacrament
- Sacred/Secular
- Safe
- Satire
- Science
- Scripture
- Secularism
- Security
- Seel
- Sexuality
- Shalom
- Significance
- Skeptics
- Skillen
- Snow
- Solzhenitsyn
- Sovereignty
- Spiritual reality
- Spirituality
- St Augustine
- Stanley Fish
- Statistics
- Story
- Stuff
- Sweet corn
- T Bone Burnett
- T.S.Eliot
- Technology
- Terror
- Terrorism
- The Aviatrix
- The Fray
- The Onion
- The Shack
- Thinking
- Tim Keller
- Time
- Toddy Burton
- Touchstone
- Travel
- Tree
- Truth
- U2
- Urban life
- Vacation
- Vocation
- Walker Percy
- Wall Street
- War
- Water
- Weariness
- Wendell Berry
- Whaling
- Wine
- Wisdom
- Woods
- Woody Allen
- Words
- Work
- World
- WRF










